bison

AI Arena · 2026-11-19

Mislabeled Boxes Logic Puzzle Solved: GPT vs Claude vs Gemini

Prompt: Solve this logic puzzle: three boxes are labeled apples, oranges, and mixed, but all labels are wrong. How can I figure out every box by picking just one fruit?

GPT-6.2 Sol

Pick one fruit from the box labeled “mixed.” Since every label is wrong, this box contains only one kind of fruit. Whatever you pull out tells you what’s in it.

If you pull an apple, that box is all apples. The box labeled “oranges” can’t contain only oranges, so it must be mixed. The box labeled “apples” is therefore all oranges.

If you pull an orange, that box is all oranges. The box labeled “apples” must be mixed, leaving the box labeled “oranges” as all apples.

Claude Sonnet 5.5

Pick one fruit from the box labeled "mixed."

Since every label is wrong, that box can't actually be mixed. It must hold only one kind of fruit, and the fruit you draw tells you which.

Suppose you draw an apple. Then the "mixed" box is apples. Now look at the other two boxes, labeled "apples" and "oranges." The box labeled "oranges" can't be oranges (wrong label) and apples are already taken, so it must be mixed. That leaves the box labeled "apples" as oranges. It can't be apples, and it can't be mixed because mixed is already taken.

So with an apple drawn: - Box labeled "mixed" = apples - Box labeled "oranges" = mixed - Box labeled "apples" = oranges

If you draw an orange instead, everything swaps: - Box labeled "mixed" = oranges - Box labeled "apples" = mixed - Box labeled "oranges" = apples

The trick is that the mixed label is the only one that guarantees a single-fruit box. Picking from either of the other boxes would leave ambiguity, because a box labeled "apples" could be either oranges or mixed, and one draw wouldn't settle which.

Gemini 4 Argon

To solve this puzzle, reach into the box labeled "Mixed" and pull out just one piece of fruit. Since all the labels are wrong, this box cannot be a mix; it must contain purely apples or purely oranges.

Suppose the fruit you pull out is an apple. Because the "Mixed" box is not actually mixed, you now know for a fact that this entire box contains only apples.

Next, look at the box labeled "Oranges." Since its label is also wrong, it cannot contain oranges. And since you already found the box of apples, the "Oranges" box must be the one that is actually mixed.

By process of elimination, the remaining box labeled "Apples" must contain only oranges.

If you happen to pull an orange from the "Mixed" box first, the exact same logic applies in reverse. That box holds only oranges, the "Apples" box is actually mixed, and the "Oranges" box holds only apples.

Grok 4.7

All labels are wrong, so the box marked mixed is pure apples or pure oranges. Draw one fruit from that box. Whatever you draw is the true contents of that box.

Suppose you draw an apple. Then the box labeled oranges cannot be oranges, and it also cannot be apples, so it must be mixed. The remaining box, labeled apples, is therefore oranges.

If you draw an orange instead, the box labeled apples must be mixed, and the box labeled oranges is apples. One draw identifies every box.

What stood out

All four models solve the puzzle correctly with the same core logic, so the differences are in depth and style. Claude is most thorough, Grok most terse, and GPT and Gemini sit in between.

Best pick, by need

Answers were generated on 2026-11-19 with default settings and one attempt each. Results vary from run to run.

Test your own prompt on all four.

Bison sends one prompt to up to six models and shows the answers side by side. Free plan, no card.

Try Bison free

More matchups