bison

AI Arena · 2026-11-19

Wolf, Goat, Cabbage Puzzle Solved: GPT vs Claude vs Gemini vs Grok

Prompt: Solve the classic river crossing puzzle with a wolf, goat, and cabbage, and explain step by step why each move works so I can understand the logic.

GPT-6.2 Sol

The boat carries you and at most one passenger or item. You can’t leave the wolf alone with the goat, or the goat alone with the cabbage.

1. Take the goat across. The wolf and cabbage can safely stay together. 2. Return alone. The goat is safe by itself. 3. Take the wolf across. You’re there to keep it from eating the goat. 4. Bring the goat back. This leaves the wolf alone on the far bank; you’re with the goat and cabbage on the starting bank. 5. Take the cabbage across. The goat is alone on the starting bank, and the wolf won’t eat the cabbage. 6. Return alone. The wolf and cabbage are safe together. 7. Take the goat across again. Everyone is now on the far bank, with you there to supervise.

The key is bringing the goat back temporarily so you can get the wolf and cabbage together without leaving either alone with the goat.

Claude Sonnet 5.5

The rules: the farmer's boat carries him plus one item. The wolf can't be left alone with the goat, and the goat can't be left alone with the cabbage.

Step 1: Take the goat across. This leaves the wolf and cabbage together, which is safe because wolves don't eat cabbage. The goat is the problem item, so it goes first.

Step 2: Return alone. The goat stays safely on the far side.

Step 3: Take the wolf across. Now the wolf and goat are together on the far side, which is dangerous, so the next step fixes it.

Step 4: Bring the goat back. The wolf stays on the far side, and the goat returns with you. This is the key move, since it breaks up the wolf-goat pair.

Step 5: Take the cabbage across, leaving the goat alone on the starting side. The wolf and cabbage are now together on the far side, which is safe.

Step 6: Return alone, leaving the wolf and cabbage safe together.

Step 7: Take the goat across one final time. Everyone is across.

The logic: the goat is in both dangerous pairs, so it must never be left with either other item. Bringing it back once lets you swap the wolf for the cabbage safely.

Gemini 4 Argon

To solve the puzzle, notice the goat is the common problem: the wolf eats the goat, and the goat eats the cabbage. The wolf and cabbage are safe together.

First, take the goat across the river. This is the only valid first move because the wolf and cabbage won't harm each other while you are gone.

Second, return to the starting side alone, leaving the goat safely on the far bank.

Third, take the wolf across.

Fourth, drop off the wolf, pick up the goat, and bring the goat back to the start. Bringing an item back is the clever trick of this puzzle, preventing the wolf from eating the goat.

Fifth, leave the goat at the start and take the cabbage across. Now the wolf and cabbage are safely together on the far side.

Sixth, return alone to the starting bank.

Finally, take the goat across the river. Everyone is now safely on the other side.

Grok 4.7

The farmer must cross a river with a wolf, a goat, and a cabbage. The boat holds only the farmer plus one passenger. Left alone, the wolf eats the goat, and the goat eats the cabbage. The farmer must therefore always stay with any unsafe pair.

First, take the goat across and return alone. The wolf and cabbage are safe together.

Next, take either the wolf or the cabbage across, then bring the goat back. This prevents the newly crossed animal or cabbage from being left with the goat.

Then take the remaining item across and return alone. Finally, bring the goat across.

Every crossing keeps the farmer present whenever the goat would otherwise be left with the wolf or cabbage. Seven crossings solve it.

What stood out

All four solve the puzzle correctly. Claude best satisfies the request for step-by-step logic, while Grok is briefest and offers an alternative but explains each move least.

Best pick, by need

Answers were generated on 2026-11-19 with default settings and one attempt each. Results vary from run to run.

Test your own prompt on all four.

Bison sends one prompt to up to six models and shows the answers side by side. Free plan, no card.

Try Bison free

More matchups