bison

AI Arena · 2026-11-19

Monty Hall Problem Explained: GPT vs Claude vs Gemini vs Grok

Prompt: Solve the Monty Hall problem: why does switching doors give a 2/3 chance of winning? Explain step by step with a simple table, and address why it feels like 50/50.

GPT-6.2 Sol

Suppose you pick Door 1. The prize is equally likely to be behind any of the three doors. Monty knows where it is, always opens a door you didn’t pick that has a goat, and always offers you the chance to switch.

Prize behind | Monty opens | Stay | Switch Door 1 | Door 2 or 3 | Win | Lose Door 2 | Door 3 | Lose | Win Door 3 | Door 2 | Lose | Win

Each row has a 1/3 chance. Staying wins only when your first pick was right. Switching wins whenever your first pick was wrong, which happens 2/3 of the time.

It feels like 50/50 because two doors remain. But Monty didn’t remove a door at random: he deliberately showed you a goat. If your first pick was wrong, he had to leave the prize door closed. That’s why switching wins in both rows where you started out wrong.

Claude Sonnet 5.5

Setup: three doors, one car, two goats. You pick a door. The host, who knows where the car is, always opens a different door showing a goat, then offers a switch.

Say you pick Door 1. Each case below happens with probability 1/3:

Car location | Host opens | Stay | Switch Door 1 | Door 2 or 3 | Win | Lose Door 2 | Door 3 | Lose | Win Door 3 | Door 2 | Lose | Win

Staying wins in 1 of 3 cases. Switching wins in 2 of 3.

The key idea: your first pick has a 1/3 chance of being right, and nothing the host does changes that, because he can always reveal a goat. The other 2/3 probability, which was spread over the two other doors, now concentrates on the one door he left closed.

Why it feels like 50/50: two doors remain, one car, so it seems symmetrical. But the doors aren't equivalent. Your door was chosen randomly, while the host's remaining door was filtered by his knowledge. He avoided the car if he could, so its being left closed is informative.

Intuition check: with 100 doors, you pick one, and the host opens 98 goat doors. Would you switch to the one door he carefully skipped? Yes, and the logic is identical.

Gemini 4 Argon

Imagine the Car is behind Door 1, and Goats are behind Doors 2 and 3.

Step 1: You pick a door. You have a 1/3 chance of picking the Car, and a 2/3 chance of picking a Goat. Step 2: Monty, who knows where the Car is, opens a different door to reveal a Goat. Step 3: You decide whether to stay or switch.

Here are the three equally likely outcomes based on your initial pick:

Your Pick | Monty Opens | If You Stay | If You Switch Door 1 (Car) | Door 2 or 3 | WIN | Lose Door 2 (Goat) | Door 3 (Goat) | Lose | WIN (Door 1) Door 3 (Goat) | Door 2 (Goat) | Lose | WIN (Door 1)

Switching wins in 2 out of 3 scenarios. If you start with a Goat (2/3 chance), Monty is forced to eliminate the only other Goat, meaning the remaining closed door must have the Car.

It feels like 50/50 because two doors remain. However, probabilities are only equal when choices are random. Monty’s choice is not random; his insider knowledge transfers the entire 2/3 probability of the two unpicked doors onto the single remaining door.

Grok 4.7

Switching wins with probability 2/3 because Monty reveals a goat from a door you did not pick, so the other unopened door collects the probability that was on the two doors you rejected.

Assume the prize is equally likely behind any door and you always start with door 1. Monty opens a goat door; if both remaining doors have goats, he picks one at random. Outcomes:

Prize | Monty opens | Switch wins? 1 | 2 or 3 | No 2 | 3 | Yes 3 | 2 | Yes

The first row has probability 1/3; the other two together have 2/3. So staying wins 1/3 and switching wins 2/3.

It feels like 50/50 because, after the reveal, two doors remain and the prize seems equally likely behind either. That ignores the setup: your first pick was right only 1/3 of the time, and Monty’s forced reveal does not move that 1/3 onto your door. It concentrates the remaining 2/3 on the other unopened door.

What stood out

All four reach the correct 2/3 answer with a similar table, so accuracy does not separate them. Claude offers the deepest intuition, GPT balance, Gemini step structure, and Grok brevity.

Best pick, by need

Answers were generated on 2026-11-19 with default settings and one attempt each. Results vary from run to run.

Test your own prompt on all four.

Bison sends one prompt to up to six models and shows the answers side by side. Free plan, no card.

Try Bison free

More matchups