bison

AI Arena · 2026-11-19

Knights and knaves puzzle explained: GPT vs Claude vs Gemini vs Grok

Prompt: Solve the knights and knaves puzzle: I meet two people, A says 'at least one of us is a knave.' Who is the knight and who is the knave? Explain the reasoning.

GPT-6.2 Sol

A is the knight, and the other person, B, is the knave.

If A were a knave, then “at least one of us is a knave” would be true, because A would be a knave. But knaves always lie, so that’s impossible.

Therefore A is a knight and is telling the truth. Since A isn’t a knave, B must be the knave.

Claude Sonnet 5.5

Assume the usual rules: knights always tell the truth, knaves always lie.

Suppose A is a knave. Then A's statement, "at least one of us is a knave," would be a lie. But if A is a knave, the statement is actually true, since A is one of the knaves. A knave can't make a true statement, so this is a contradiction.

So A must be a knight. Since A tells the truth, at least one of the two of us is a knave. A is a knight, so the knave must be B.

Answer: A is the knight and B is the knave.

Check: A's statement is true because B is a knave, which fits a knight. The puzzle gives no statement from B, so B being a knave is forced purely by A's truthful claim.

Gemini 4 Argon

A is the knight and B is the knave.

In these puzzles, knights always tell the truth and knaves always lie. We can solve this by testing the two possibilities for A.

First, suppose A is a knave. This means A's statement, "at least one of us is a knave," must be a lie. However, if A is a knave, then it is actually true that at least one of them is a knave. Since a knave cannot make a true statement, this creates a contradiction. Therefore, A cannot be a knave.

Since A is not a knave, A must be a knight. This means A's statement is completely true. For the statement "at least one of us is a knave" to be true when A is already a knight, the other person, B, must be the knave.

Thus, A is a knight and B is a knave.

Grok 4.7

A is a knight and B is a knave.

Knights always tell the truth and knaves always lie. A claims that at least one of them is a knave. If A were a knave, that claim would be false, so both would be knights—which contradicts A being a knave. So A must be a knight, the claim is true, and therefore B is the knave.

What stood out

All four models answer correctly. Claude explains and verifies most fully, Gemini and GPT are clear and concise, and Grok is briefest but its argument is the least rigorous.

Best pick, by need

Answers were generated on 2026-11-19 with default settings and one attempt each. Results vary from run to run.

Test your own prompt on all four.

Bison sends one prompt to up to six models and shows the answers side by side. Free plan, no card.

Try Bison free

More matchups