bison

AI Arena · 2026-11-19

Solve a Mixture Word Problem: GPT vs Claude vs Gemini vs Grok

Prompt: Help me solve this mixture word problem: How many liters of 20% saline solution must I mix with 10% saline solution to get 30 liters of 14% solution? Show the setup.

GPT-6.2 Sol

Let x be the liters of 20% saline solution. Then 30 − x is the liters of 10% saline solution.

The amount of salt from both solutions must equal the amount in 30 liters of 14% solution:

0.20x + 0.10(30 − x) = 0.14(30)

Simplify: 0.10x + 3 = 4.2, so 0.10x = 1.2 and x = 12.

Mix 12 liters of 20% solution with 18 liters of 10% solution.

Claude Sonnet 5.5

Let x = liters of 20% solution. Then the 10% solution is 30 − x liters.

Setup: the amount of salt before mixing equals the amount of salt after mixing.

0.20x + 0.10(30 − x) = 0.14(30)

Solve:

0.20x + 3 − 0.10x = 4.2 0.10x + 3 = 4.2 0.10x = 1.2 x = 12

So you need 12 liters of the 20% solution and 30 − 12 = 18 liters of the 10% solution.

Check: salt from the 20% solution is 0.20(12) = 2.4 L, and salt from the 10% solution is 0.10(18) = 1.8 L. The total is 4.2 L of salt in 30 L, and 4.2/30 = 0.14, which is 14%. It works.

Quick shortcut: the target 14% is 4 points above 10% and 6 points below 20%. The mixing ratio is therefore 4 parts of the 20% solution to 6 parts of the 10% solution, or 2:3. Splitting 30 L in a 2:3 ratio gives 12 L and 18 L.

Gemini 4 Argon

Let x be the liters of the 20% saline solution you need. Since the final mixture is 30 liters total, the remaining amount is the 10% solution, which we can write as (30 - x) liters.

Next, set up an equation by calculating the amount of pure salt in each part. The salt from the 20% solution plus the salt from the 10% solution must equal the salt in the final 14% mixture.

Using decimals for the percentages, here is the setup: 0.20x + 0.10(30 - x) = 0.14(30)

Now, solve for x. First, multiply the terms in parentheses: 0.20x + 3 - 0.10x = 4.2

Combine the x terms on the left side: 0.10x + 3 = 4.2

Subtract 3 from both sides: 0.10x = 1.2

Finally, divide by 0.10 to find x: x = 12

You must mix 12 liters of the 20% saline solution (with 18 liters of the 10% solution) to get your final mixture.

Grok 4.7

Let x be the liters of 20% saline. Then 30 - x liters are 10% saline.

The salt balance is 0.20x + 0.10(30 - x) = 0.14 × 30.

Solving gives 0.10x + 3 = 4.2, so x = 12.

You need 12 liters of the 20% solution (and 18 liters of the 10% solution).

What stood out

All four are correct and use the same setup; they differ in depth. Claude adds a check and a shortcut, Gemini explains each step, GPT is balanced, and Grok is the briefest.

Best pick, by need

Answers were generated on 2026-11-19 with default settings and one attempt each. Results vary from run to run.

Test your own prompt on all four.

Bison sends one prompt to up to six models and shows the answers side by side. Free plan, no card.

Try Bison free

More matchups